Splitifi CanadaCA
JusticeProvincial (Ontario)

Justice Margaret Hennessy

Ontario

Judicial Profile

Appointed2014
JurisdictionProvincial (Ontario)
State/ProvinceOntario
Specializations:
Parenting coordinationVoice of the childMental health issues in family law

Case Statistics

Total Cases
1,654
Avg. Days to Decision
40

Notable Cases

  • Thompson v. Thompson (2020)2020 ONSC 4892
    Pioneering decision on incorporating children's views and preferences in parenting disputes. Established protocols for Office of the Children's Lawyer involvement and appointed children's counsel to independently represent sibling perspectives. The decision examined methods for ascertaining children's wishes including judicial interviews, clinical assessments, and children's legal representation. Provided framework for weighing children's stated preferences against developmental capacity, potential influence or alienation, and best interests analysis. Emphasized importance of hearing children's voices while protecting them from inappropriate parentification or burden of decision-making.
  • Mitchell v. Saunders (2022)2022 ONSC 3245
    Comprehensive decision addressing parenting arrangements where one parent has significant mental health challenges. Carefully balanced parenting rights with child safety concerns, implementing structured parenting plan with graduated increases in parenting time contingent on treatment compliance, medication management, and demonstrated stability. The decision established monitoring protocols and benchmarks for increased parenting time, addressing stigma while prioritizing child welfare. Provided guidance on appropriate scope and limitations of psychological assessments, privacy considerations, and evidentiary standards for mental health evidence in family court.

Judicial Approach & Style

Justice Hennessy is known for her child-focused approach to family law disputes and deep understanding of child development principles. She frequently considers children's views and preferences appropriate to their age and maturity, and is comfortable appointing the Office of the Children's Lawyer or ordering Voice of the Child Reports when beneficial. Demonstrates compassion and understanding in cases involving mental health issues, substance abuse, or other challenges affecting parenting capacity, while maintaining focus on child safety and wellbeing. Encourages therapeutic interventions, parenting education, and support services. Known for creative, individualized parenting plans that reflect family circumstances rather than rigid templates. Actively manages high-conflict cases with clear expectations for parental behavior and communication. Values collaboration between parties and legal counsel to achieve child-focused resolutions.

Education & Background

Education:
  1. LLB, McMaster University
  2. BA, Child Development and Psychology, University of Guelph
Previous Roles:
  1. Family lawyer, Hennessy & Associates (2001-2014)
  2. Volunteer lawyer, Hamilton Community Legal Clinic (2006-2014)
  3. Trained Parenting Coordinator (2009-2014)

Frequently Asked Questions

When does Justice Hennessy order involvement of the Office of the Children's Lawyer?
Justice Hennessy considers Office of the Children's Lawyer (OCL) involvement when children's views and preferences would assist in determining their best interests, particularly when children are of sufficient age and maturity to express meaningful views. Common situations include parenting disputes where children have strong preferences about living arrangements, cases involving allegations of alienation or parental alignment, relocation cases where children have established communities and relationships, and complex cases where multiple factors affect best interests. The OCL may provide a clinical investigation (social work report) or legal representation for children. Justice Hennessy also considers Voice of the Child Reports as a less intensive alternative where appropriate. Parties should be aware that OCL involvement adds time and cost to proceedings but provides valuable independent perspective focused on children's interests.
How does Justice Hennessy handle cases involving mental health concerns?
Justice Hennessy approaches mental health issues with both sensitivity and appropriate caution. She recognizes that mental health challenges alone do not preclude effective parenting, but carefully assesses how symptoms, treatment compliance, and stability affect parenting capacity and child safety. She may order psychological assessments, parenting capacity evaluations, or section 30 assessments under the Children's Law Reform Act. Justice Hennessy considers evidence of treatment engagement, medication compliance, support systems, insight into the condition's impact on parenting, and stability over time. She may implement graduated parenting plans that allow for increased time as stability is demonstrated, with clear benchmarks and monitoring mechanisms. Parties with mental health challenges should be prepared to provide evidence of ongoing treatment, demonstrate insight and stability, and propose safety protocols if needed. Justice Hennessy values honest, non-stigmatizing discussions about mental health while keeping child welfare paramount.
What should I expect regarding children's participation in proceedings?
Justice Hennessy believes in hearing children's voices where appropriate while protecting them from the adversarial process. She will not permit children to testify in court except in extraordinary circumstances. Instead, children's views may be presented through Office of the Children's Lawyer reports, Voice of the Child Reports, or in rare cases, judicial interviews conducted in chambers. The weight given to children's expressed preferences depends on their age, maturity, consistency of views, reasoning behind preferences, and evidence of influence or coaching. Justice Hennessy is attuned to situations where children's stated preferences may reflect loyalty conflicts, fear, or parental influence rather than authentic wishes. She emphasizes that children should never feel responsible for deciding between parents. Parties should not involve children in litigation, share court documents with them, or question them about preferences. Focus should remain on demonstrating your own parenting abilities rather than using children as witnesses or messengers.

Court Information

Jurisdiction:Provincial (Ontario)
Location:Ontario

Court Preparation

  • ✓ Research judge's specializations
  • ✓ Review notable case decisions
  • ✓ Prepare thorough documentation
  • ✓ Be punctual and professional
  • ✓ Focus on children's best interests

Prepare for Court with Confidence

Splitifi provides judge-specific insights, court document generation, and AI-powered preparation tools for your Canada family law case.

We use cookies to understand how the site is used and, with your permission, for advertising and session recording. We never use them on signed-in pages. See our Privacy Policy.