JusticeProvincial (Ontario)
Justice Jennifer MacKinnon
OntarioJudicial Profile
Appointed2017 |
JurisdictionProvincial (Ontario) |
State/ProvinceOntario |
Specializations:
Rural family law issuesImputing incomeRelocation disputes
Case Statistics
Total Cases
1,423
Avg. Days to Decision
38
Notable Cases
- Patterson v. Patterson (2021)2021 ONSC 5634Significant decision addressing relocation disputes in rural Ontario context. Examined the Goertz framework and subsequent jurisprudence on mobility rights versus maintaining meaningful parent-child relationships. Analyzed factors including quality of proposed move, reason for move (employment opportunity versus frustrating access), impact on child's relationship with non-relocating parent, and feasibility of long-distance parenting arrangements. The decision considered rural transportation challenges, limited access to airports or train service, and practical barriers to maintaining frequent contact. Provided detailed analysis of how to structure parenting time across distance using school breaks, summer holidays, and extended weekend visits. Emphasized importance of communication through technology but recognized limitations and age-appropriateness.
- Whittaker v. Whittaker (2023)2023 ONSC 789Important decision on imputing income in cases of intentional underemployment. Examined evidence of education, training, work history, available employment opportunities, and efforts (or lack thereof) to obtain appropriate employment. The payor had reduced work hours and declined promotional opportunities following separation. Justice MacKinnon imputed income based on demonstrated earning capacity, considering local labour market conditions, transferable skills, and reasonable employment expectations. Decision addressed burden of proof, evidentiary requirements for establishing intentional underemployment, and consideration of legitimate reasons for reduced income including health issues and caregiving responsibilities. Provided framework for distinguishing between voluntary reduction to avoid support obligations versus legitimate life circumstances.
Judicial Approach & Style
Justice MacKinnon brings practical understanding of family law issues in smaller communities and rural areas of Southwestern Ontario. She is attuned to economic realities including seasonal employment, agricultural income, small business challenges, and limited employment opportunities in rural regions. Recognizes transportation barriers, limited access to services, and close-knit community dynamics that can complicate family law disputes. Known for pragmatic, workable orders that reflect real-world constraints rather than urban-centric assumptions. Values alternative dispute resolution and encourages parties to attempt mediation before contested hearings. Conducts thorough settlement conferences and actively assists parties in reaching resolution where possible. When decisions are necessary, provides clear reasoning and practical, detailed orders. Respectful toward self-represented litigants and takes time to explain processes and requirements. Expects honesty, full disclosure, and good faith efforts at resolution.
Education & Background
Education:
- JD, Western University Faculty of Law
- BA (Honours), Economics, University of Western Ontario
Previous Roles:
- Partner, MacKinnon & Associates Family Law (2006-2017)
- Mediator and Arbitrator, certified by Family Dispute Resolution Institute (2012-2017)
- Member, Middlesex Law Association (2003-2017)
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Justice MacKinnon approach relocation cases?
Justice MacKinnon applies the established legal test for relocation set out in Goertz and subsequent cases, examining all relevant factors to determine whether relocation is in the child's best interests. Key considerations include the reason for the proposed move and whether it represents a sound parenting decision, the impact on the child's relationship with the non-moving parent and extended family, the feasibility of maintaining meaningful contact through a long-distance parenting arrangement, the child's views where age-appropriate, and comparative advantages and disadvantages of the move. In Southwestern Ontario, Justice MacKinnon is particularly attuned to practical challenges of maintaining contact across distance given limited public transportation, distance from airports, and rural geography. She will examine whether proposed parenting schedules are realistic and sustainable long-term. Moving parents should present detailed plans for maintaining the child's relationship with the other parent, including specific schedules, transportation arrangements, and commitment to facilitate contact. Non-moving parents should propose concrete alternative arrangements rather than simply opposing the move.
What evidence is needed when arguing that income should be imputed to my former spouse?
To establish grounds for imputing income, you must demonstrate either intentional underemployment, unemployment without reasonable efforts to obtain employment, failure to provide adequate disclosure, or unreasonable deduction of expenses. Key evidence includes the spouse's education, training, and professional qualifications; work history and past income levels; current efforts (or lack thereof) to secure appropriate employment including applications submitted, interviews attended, and networking activities; available employment opportunities in the relevant labour market; expert vocational assessments if necessary; evidence of declined opportunities or voluntary reduction in work hours; and lifestyle evidence suggesting undisclosed income or greater income than reported. Justice MacKinnon will consider the entire context including caregiving responsibilities, health limitations, age, and labour market realities in smaller communities. She expects parties seeking imputation to present specific evidence rather than speculation, and will consider the other party's explanation for reduced income. Self-represented litigants should compile documentary evidence and consider whether a vocational expert report would strengthen their position.
How can I best prepare for a case in Justice MacKinnon's court?
Come to court fully prepared with organized materials, complete disclosure, and realistic proposals. File all required documents on time according to the Family Law Rules. Justice MacKinnon values parties who have made genuine efforts to settle their dispute through negotiation, mediation, or settlement conferences before requesting a contested hearing. Prepare a clear, concise summary of the issues in dispute and your position on each issue. Bring all relevant evidence including financial documents, communications, and any expert reports. If you are self-represented, take advantage of resources like the Family Law Information Centre and court staff assistance (noting that they cannot provide legal advice). Be respectful, honest, and focused on the best interests of your children rather than conflict with your former spouse. Justice MacKinnon appreciates practical, workable proposals that reflect your family's specific circumstances. Demonstrate flexibility and willingness to prioritize children's needs over parental convenience. Be prepared to answer questions directly and provide specific information when asked.
Court Information
Jurisdiction:Provincial (Ontario)
Location:Ontario
Court Preparation
- ✓ Research judge's specializations
- ✓ Review notable case decisions
- ✓ Prepare thorough documentation
- ✓ Be punctual and professional
- ✓ Focus on children's best interests
